Saretto · Italian Supper Club in Historic Downtown Martinsburg, WV
Saretto
Est. 2022 · 109 N. Queen St.

You found us.

An Italian supper club hidden in plain sight on Queen Street. Cocktails poured from Al Capone’s bar. The password, as always, is hungry.

Chef Paul Stearman garnishing pasta in a dimly lit kitchen
— From the kitchen —

Paul Stearman, plating in the dark.

Chef Paul brings a Washington D.C. pedigree to a small dining room on Queen Street — house-made pastas, hand-rolled meatballs, dry-aged steaks, and a kitchen that cooks like it matters every night.

Chef · Paul Stearman · formerly of Washington, D.C.
— The Bar —

It poured for Capone. Now it pours for you.

The mahogany centerpiece of our dining room once stood in one of Al Capone’s Chicago haunts during Prohibition. A century later, it pours for guests in West Virginia. Sit at it. Order something dark.

Warm lighting, rich wood, and an elegant bar that gives the whole room its heart.— Yelp review, 2025
See the bar list →
— Signature pours —

Order something dark.

A few favorites from the list. “The Godfather” is on the menu because someone has to make the joke.

The Godfather

Lagavulin, Disaronno, orange peel

— 14

Ceasar’s Old Fashioned

Black walnut bourbon, bitters, sugar

— 12

Paper Airplane

Black Draft bourbon, amaro, Aperol, lemon

— 13
The full cocktail list →
— After the lamps go down —

Comedy. Karaoke. Cocktails.

Dinner is the opening act. The bar stays open later — and there’s almost always something happening on stage.

Monthly

Open Mic Comedy

Local comics, the occasional D.C. headliner. Tickets at the door.

Weekly

Karaoke Night

Singers welcome. Hecklers tolerated. Cocktails poured by Marie.

Call for this week’s schedule →
— Find us · Reach us —

The essentials

Hours

Tue — Sat 5 p.m. — midnight
Closed Sun & Mon

Find Us

109 N. Queen St Martinsburg, WV 25401

Private Events

Weddings, parties, catering & food truck

Common Q’s

Reservations, the Capone bar, dietary, takeout
Reserve · (681) 247-1338